Candy Corn
Pretty much nobody likes Candy Corn, and yet it was given as a "treat" by the Nightmare Imp during the 2022 Halloween Trick or Treat Event.Wizards, Warriors, Souls, and Friends traveled through the Vampyre Mist to knock on the Imp's door to receive a surprise. Some candy corns are now kept in the Forgotten Runes Athenaeum.
Rarity
The Nightmare Imp gave out 162 total Candy Corns.